What Is The Difference between Roots Blower And Screw Blower?

Roots blowers and screw blowers are two common types of compressors in the industrial field. They have their own characteristics and application areas in providing gas compression solutions. Although both types of fans are functionally designed for gas compression, there are significant differences in their design concepts, working principles, and performance characteristics. The similarities and differences between Roots blowers and screw blowers will be elaborated below:

Similarities:

1. The same purpose: Whether it is a Roots blower or a screw blower, they are both positive displacement blowers, and their ultimate goal is to provide a stable pressure and flow output to meet various industrial and commercial needs.

2. Industrial applications: Both are widely used in industrial fields, such as sewage treatment, pneumatic transportation, pneumatic circulation, etc.

3. Continuous operation: Both Roots blowers and screw blowers are designed for long-term continuous operation to meet the continuous needs of industrial production.

4. Configuration requirements: In the system, both may need to be equipped with corresponding control systems and safety devices to ensure the stability and safety of operation.

5. Importance of maintenance: Regular maintenance is essential for both Roots and screw blowers to maintain long-term stable operation and efficiency.

Differences：

1. Working principle:

Roots blower: Roots blower generates airflow through two or more rotating blade-shaped rotors moving relative to each other in the cylinder. When the rotor rotates, the cavity continuously inhales air and discharges it to the outside, thus generating airflow. Roots blower belongs to the "external compression" type, and there is no volume change during the conveying process, and no internal pressure change is generated (relying on the back pressure of the pipe network).

Screw blower: The screw blower uses the rotary motion of the screw inside the casing to alternately expand and reduce the working volume, thereby sucking in gas and increasing the pressure. It belongs to the "internal compression" type, and the pressure increase comes from the change in the internal volume of the main engine cavity.

2. Pressure range:

Roots blower: generally suitable for medium and low pressure range, the pressure is generally between 0.1-1 bar. For every 0.1 bar increase in working pressure, the outlet temperature rises by 10℃.

Screw blower: can generate higher pressure, usually up to 2-10 bar, suitable for environments requiring higher pressure. For every 0.1 bar increase in working pressure, the outlet temperature rises by 8°C.

3. Flow stability:

Roots blower: Due to the influence of centrifugal force, the pulse is large, and the pulse torque will produce intermittent noise and vibration. The flow stability at the outlet is slightly inferior to that of the screw blower.

Screw blower: The airflow is smoother, with good continuity, less leakage, and low pressure pulse, which is suitable for application scenarios with high requirements for stability.

4. Noise and vibration:

Roots blower: Due to the structure of the rotating parts, it usually produces higher noise and vibration, up to around 110-120 decibels.

Screw blower：relatively quiet, with less vibration, suitable for places with strict requirements on noise, generally around 60-85 decibels.

5. Maintenance cost:

Roots blower: The maintenance cost is low, but the high precision requirement may lead to increased maintenance difficulty and cost. At the same time, the failure rate is high during long-term operation, so one is used and one is spare.

Screw blower: The initial investment is high, but the energy consumption and maintenance costs are low in the long run, especially with the increase of usage time and equipment pressure, the advantages are more obvious, and it can operate continuously.

6. Application areas:

Roots blower: more suitable for occasions with large flow and relatively low pressure requirements, such as aeration tanks for sewage treatment.

Screw blower: suitable for industrial applications that require higher pressure and stable airflow, such as gas compression in chemical processes.

7. Efficiency:

Roots blower: Under standard operating conditions, Roots blowers have low operating efficiency and may be affected by gas backflow and leakage.

Screw blower: Due to the internal compression process, screw blowers have high operating efficiency and stable gas supply, but thermal efficiency is usually higher when working at high pressure

8. Service life:

Roots blower: simple structure, long service life, but may be easily damaged under high pressure.

Screw blower: complex structure leads to increased cost, but reasonable maintenance can ensure a long service life.

When choosing a Roots blower or a screw blower, the following factors need to be considered:

(1) Consider the requirements of the actual application scenario: flow rate, pressure, etc.

(2) Evaluate long-term operating costs: including energy consumption and maintenance costs.

(3) Consider the stability of the equipment and the impact of noise on the working environment.

Summary: Roots blowers and screw blowers have their own characteristics, and the choice should be based on the needs and scenario conditions of the specific application. Roots blowers are suitable for occasions with large flow and low pressure requirements, while screw blowers are more suitable for applications that require high pressure and stable airflow.

NANJING HAISI is professional manufacturer of plastic extruder, we supply Twin Screw Extruder, Single Screw Extruder, Plastic Recycling Extruder, Two Stage Extruder, Lab Scale Extruder, Mixing and Feeding Machine, Cooling and Pelletizing Machine, Crushing Machine and so on.